Simon-Kucher & Partners vs Arthur D Little
I am deciding between these two firms in the US (have final offer) -- anyone have any thoughts on pros and cons of each?
Here are my thoughts:
strong presence in Europe, trying to grow/recover after a buyout in the US
strong inTMT, automotive, tech-heavy industries
Simon-Kucher & Partners:
strong in pricing/marketing and able tocompete withMBBin this area
growing in US
Both companies seem to have decent/similar culture, with the tradeoff being a more narrow functional area at SKP vs a slightly lower industry reputation at ADL, potentially affecting exit opps and b-school placement.
Comments (7)
Internship or FT? What offices?
ADL has about 100 people in the US v Simon Kucher which has about 350 (coming from LinkedIn) so ADL's US operation is really small and I'm not sure they're looking to grow this either-feel free to correct me. I do know that Simon Kucher is looking to grow their practice in the US. SKP has a better repuation and I'd consider it a lower T2.
> SKP has a better repuation and I'd consider it a lower T2.
Until people accept cross offers for them over the T2s (S&/EY-P/ATK/LEK/OW) and they're not tiny, I certainly wouldn't
You have a point on them still being small but cross-offers is only one aspect of where a firm ranks. I was moreso looking at quality of work, quality of people, ability to win head-to-heads, etc. But yeah, until they beef up in size they're still essentially a boutique.
I would not in general say they are comparable to T2s in terms of quality of work, quality of people, or ability to win head to heads. While there are a couple types of work where that may be true, I'd say that that's kind of the definition (or at least a definition) of a boutique
Also, I've done a lot of pricing work, and I can't think of any examples where they've come up at a client (i.e. often you'll hear about who you won/lost a pitch to, as well as who has supported the client in pricing work in the past). Obviously they do this work and may be good at it, but I'm saying I don't think they're necessarily at the caliber of competition or caliber of clients that you may have heard second hand
European brand strength does not matter for you insofar as you're not in Europe
I wouldn't be too worried about SKP having a better industry reputation or brand strength on resume - they're more similar than they are different
Three questions I would use to guide your thought process:
(1) How does comp vary between the two, from both a short term and mid-term (3-5yr) perspective?
(2) Which type of work are you more interested in?
(3) With which company did you feel like you got along with better (i.e. culture fit)?
Voluptas est iusto tempora voluptates itaque. Ipsa vel rerum ducimus voluptas officia corrupti. Est et adipisci consequatur repudiandae soluta ipsa.
Alias nisi placeat alias incidunt ut ex. Asperiores et rem est dolores. Repellat qui est repellendus.
Alias veniam quia perspiciatis optio laborum itaque. Sint possimus incidunt recusandae quas et.
Occaecati reprehenderit odit voluptatem aspernatur fuga rerum fugiat delectus. Atque rerum repellendus autem autem. Quos aut voluptas sint voluptatibus.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus:6 financial modeling lessons free($199 value)
orWant toUnlockby signing in with your social account?
Preview & download comment as image
You can download this screenshot as image or copy to clipboard using browser's context menu